2.15.2011

Participants Needed For An Online Questionnaire Study

DZ gave me permission to post this on here, so I'll be quick: I'm looking for participants to take part in a questionnaire study that explores people's experiences of asking God for something or to do something (i.e. people's petitionary prayers). It takes anywhere between 20-45 minutes to complete, is entirely anonymous, and has been approved by the University of Cambridge Research Ethics Committee.

If you would like more information or to take part in the study, please click here.

(And if you take part in the study and have comments to share with me, please email me rather than post comments here. Thank you in advance for your help - it is very much appreciated!)

Labels: , ,

1.20.2011

My 30th Birthday Playlist

If you, like me, were born in 1981, this is the year of the big 30 for you. (I turned 30 last week.) And if you, like me, have awesome friends, they may have made you a play list of songs from 1981 for your birthday. And gosh darn it, 1981 was a good year. Here's my 30th birthday play list, with a huge thanks to Collin and Candice:

1. Back in Black - AC/DC
2. All Out Of Love - Air Supply
3. 9 to 5 - Dolly Parton
4. I'm Coming Out - Diana Ross & The Supremes
5. Endless Love - Diana Ross & The Supremes
6. Waiting for a Girl Like You - Foreigner
7. Urgent - Foreigner
8. Don't Stop Believin' - Journey
9. Bette Davis Eyes - Kim Carnes
10. Physical - Olivia Newton John
11. Celebration - Kool & The Gang
12. Hit Me With Best Shot - Pat Benatar
13. Jessie's Girl - Rick Springfield
14. Don't Stand So Close To Me - Sting & The Police
15. The Best Of Times - Styx
16. Another One Bites the Dust - Queen
17. You've Lost That Lovin' Feeling - The Righteous Brothers

Labels: , ,

1.14.2011

On Religious Insight

Just a short excerpt from The Psychology of Religious Knowing by Fraser Watts and Mark Williams:

"The contrast is between insight that is merely intellectual or neutral and a second type of insight that has been variously described as true, effective, dynamic or emotional. ... Religious insight that, like therapeutic insight, has been chiseled out of experience will have more personal consequences than merely intellectual or 'notional' religious insight. Emotional and behavioural reactions are more likely to be congruent with beliefs that have been formed in this way." (p. 71, 74)

Labels: , ,

11.16.2010

The Best of Both Worlds

Labels: , , ,

11.04.2010

Quick To Judge And Slow To Forgive...

Following on DPotter's recent post about how Americans are slow to forgive, I'm sure you've been (or are quickly becoming) aware of the internet's reaction over how a food magazine used a piece of writing without the writer's permission, and instead of offering an apology, the editor told the author of the article that she (the author) should compensate the magazine for editing her work for her. Now, hell hath no fury like the internet community sticking up for a writer plagiarized (apparently the original phrase "hell hath no fury..." is by William Congreve, whom I had never heard of): the magazine's Facebook page is now exploding with angry (not to mention smart, sarcastic, and often rude) comments.

I'm of course not condoning the words or actions of the magazine editor - I think what she said was absolutely ridiculous, rude, and entitled - and judging from what others have continued to say, apparently her apology was anything but genuine. (As much as I would like to feel bad for the editor lady, I don't...) A real-time example of the sort of judgement that we are so good at giving and would hate to receive ourselves, and of how our forgiveness is so often conditional on the right apology being offered--which is so drastically different to the forgiveness offered to us on the Cross!

Labels: , ,

10.22.2010

Scientists successfully teach gorilla that it will die some day

Following on from DZ's earlier post on talking to kids about God and all the moral/ethical/theological issues surrounding it, here is a genius piece from The Onion about teaching a gorilla about the concept of mortality:

Labels: , ,

10.12.2010

Me, My Oughts, and I

The penultimate installment in our series of entries from Judgment & Love, here is Bonnie's chapter. Again, J&L is a collection of 35 true-life stories illustrating the powerful truth that when love is shown in the face of deserved judgment, lives are changed. To order your copy at the reduced price of $10, go here or click on the button at the bottom of the post.

Like most teenagers living in developed countries, I worried about the way I looked. I knew I wasn’t fat, and even though I wasn’t quite as thin as some other girls, it didn’t really bother me at all since there were always other characteristics that made me feel good about myself—good grades, a lot of self confidence, a happy personality, and good friends. My body was never a very large part of my identity until I lived abroad and gained twenty-five pounds over six months. Somehow, that set off a siren in my head that something was not okay: I was “fat.” Not knowing what to do (and never having been on a diet before), I resorted to desperate measures to remove this “bad” part of my self-image: I developed an eating disorder.

According to Biological Psychiatry, 80% of women in the United States exhibit signs of an eating disorder at some stage; between 1-5% of adolescent women meet the criteria for diagnosis of an eating disorder, including an estimated 19-30% of college-age women. I became a statistic.

Some girls revel in their ability to manipulate how much they eat. When I was in high school, I remember a girl triumphantly told me she had only eaten three mints over an entire day; I thought that was the stupidest thing I had ever heard. Another girl told me about how to manipulate your throat to make yourself gag; that grossed me out. When I became desperate enough, however, these strategies seemed less strange and more “effective.” I thought I could stop once I had lost the twenty-five pounds. But I didn’t.

At this point you might say, “Oh, but you didn’t know better.” Of course I knew better. I was a Christian, and I knew my identity shouldn’t be determined by how I looked: I am “a child of God,” a “temple of the Holy Spirit,” and free from the bondage of sin and death. Children of God shouldn’t have to worry about mortal bodies that will eventually turn to dust. Temples of the Holy Spirit should certainly be presentable to the Lord. Christians who have been freed from bondage shouldn’t have obsessive- compulsive disorders. But knowing these things didn’t really change my behavior—in fact, it made me feel worse about myself. I would be reminded of my identity in God and the promise of God’s deliverance during my morning quiet time, and four hours later at lunch I would either not eat, eat too much, or count the calories in my salad with tuna (no dressing), and feel like a complete failure.

I talked to counselors and other Christians, had account- ability partners, read books, and prayed that something would change. I had already lost the twenty-five pounds, maybe more, and looked terrible. But I didn’t and couldn’t stop, and I hated myself for it. (I figured that God probably didn’t hate me, but He wasn’t going to be entirely happy with me until I shaped up.)
[CONTINUE READING]

Labels: , , , ,

8.13.2010

Announcing The Gospel According to Pixar!!

Beginning with Toy Story in 1995, Pixar Animation Studios has taken American cinema by storm, setting a new standard of excellence in animated filmmaking and earning a fortune in the process. Their movies are not only highly entertaining but wise. Pixar has an all-too-rare gift for telling stories which speak about the reality of life and complexities of the human heart - and making us laugh while doing so.

Mockingbird's brand-new publication, The Gospel According to Pixar, looks at how each Pixar film portrays the basic concerns of everyday life and seeks to connect them with a Christian understanding of the world. Using imaginative stories about fish, monsters, and cars, Pixar films touch on such deeply human themes as love, identity, suffering, forgiveness, fear, freedom, guilt, purpose and belonging - to name just a few. These common concerns allow for easy avenues of dialogue between the films and Christianity, which The Gospel According to Pixar explores in hopes of communicating the Gospel in a fresh and persuasive way.

Written for a broad, all-ages audience, it can be used as a teaching series, a study guide, or simply as a commentary. And like the films themselves, we hope The Gospel According to Pixar is as moving as it is fun. Edited by Todd Brewer and David Zahl, and also featuring entries from blog contributors Bonnie, Nick Lannon and L.R.E. Larkin, we could not be more proud of it. The table of contents looks like this:
[CONTINUE READING]

Labels: , , , , , , , , , , , , ,

6.22.2010

I like it, so God would like it too: Egocentrism in believer's estimates of God's belief

Religion is often seen as a moral compass - it is frequently used by believers as a guide to doing and believing the right thing. People may disagree on social issues like abortion, same-sex marriage, and the death penalty and back their opinions by invoking God as the ultimate advocate of their beliefs. But how do people reason about God's beliefs? In an interesting set of six studies by Nick Epley and colleagues, it was argued that people are remarkably egocentric when asked to infer about God's beliefs--that is, people seem to draw on their own beliefs about these issues when asked to infer what God's beliefs about the same issues may be.

In the first four studies, participants (most of whom believed in God) were asked to report their own belief about an issue, and then estimated God's belief along with some other targets' (specifically Bill Gates', George Bush, and the Average American's) beliefs about the same issue. The issues in question included abortion, same-sex marriage, affirmative action, death penalty, the Iraq war, and Marijuana legalization. Epley and colleagues calculated an "egocentric correlation" between participants' own attitudes and their estimates of the other targets' attitudes. They found that the egocentric correlation between self and God's beliefs were larger than the egocentric correlation between the self and all other targets.


Next, the researchers experimentally manipulated people's own beliefs to see if it would also affect their estimates of God's beliefs. People's attitudes towards affirmative action were manipulated by exposing them to persuasive arguments for or against affirmative action. People who were exposed to a persuasive pro-policy message were more likely to say that God also supported affirmative action, and the egocentric correlation between self and God was again higher than the correlations between self and the other targets. The researchers also manipulated people's existing attitudes by asking them to write and deliver a speech that was either consistent or inconsistent with their own views about an issue like the death penalty. Those who wrote and delivered a speech that was consistent with their own attitudes reported stronger attitudes about the issue after giving the speech, while those who wrote and delivered a speech that was inconsistent with their own attitudes had more moderate attitudes after giving the speech. When asked what they thought God's beliefs were about the death penalty, those participants who had their attitudes strengthened (by writing and giving an attitude-consistent the speech) also said that God would have a correspondingly strong attitude, whereas those participants who had their own attitudes weakened (by writing and giving an attitude-inconsistent speech) were more likely to say that God's attitude towards the issue was also more moderate. In contrast (and most interestingly), changing people's attitudes did not affect their beliefs about Bill Gates', the Average American's, or George Bush's attitude towards the particular issue. Changing people's attitudes towards an issue also changed their view of God's attitude towards the issue.
[CONTINUE READING]

Labels: , , ,

3.16.2010

On The Relationship Between Fart And Morality

When we think about ethics and morality, we often think that it is rational. Morality requires making judgments of right and wrong, and making judgments about what is right and wrong is a matter of logic and reasoning. But researchers interested in the psychology of morality are finding that morality is much more embodied and affective than we’d like to think. Specifically, moral judgments have been found to be linked to the feeling of disgust.


Schnall, Haidt, Clore, and Jordan (2008) hypothesized that morality may be more of a gut reaction that is later justified by moral reasoning: “moral reasoning is an important part of moral life, but for most people, most of the time, most of the action is in the quick, automatic, affective evaluations they make of people and events.” (p. 1097) They tested this hypothesis in a series of awesome studies that included fart spray and dried up smoothies. (You have to acknowledge how incredibly cool it is that “fart spray” made it into a top tier psychology journal.)

The researchers asked participants to read and think about several vignettes concerning moral judgments. These vignettes ranged from personal (e.g., whether sex between first cousins is ok, whether it is wrong for someone to falsify their resume) to public (e.g., whether participants would support nondenominational school prayer, whether participants would support spending more of the state’s money for waste treatment); some of them were disgusting (e.g., eating dead dog) while others were not meant to elicit disgust (e.g., stealing). Here is the cool part: the researchers experimentally manipulated the level of disgust that participants would feel. In one study, some of the participants completed the questionnaire in a room that smelled like fart (yes, the experimenters secretly sprayed fart spray into the air), and in another study, they had to complete the questionnaire with a pen that someone had chewed up, while sitting at a table with a cup of old, dried up smoothie and some used tissues, in a chair with a dirty, worn out cushion, in a room where the trash can overflowed. (Folks in the no-disgust condition completed their questionnaires in clean, tidy rooms.) 

[CONTINUE READING]

Labels: , ,

10.22.2009

Self help...doesn't help

Does self help actually help? Apparently not as much as the self-help industry would like to think. Recent research published in Psychological Science shows that repeating positive statements about oneself, which is a common self-help strategy, doesn't always increase self esteem.

Researchers asked people to repeat positive statements about themselves, such as "I am a lovable person". They found that people who had low self esteem to begin with actually felt worse about themselves afterwards. (People with high self esteem felt just marginally better after repeating these statements.) In a second study, one group of people was asked to think only about a positive self statement, while another group was asked to think about the positive self statement as well as times when the statement was true and untrue (e.g., the statement might be "I am lovable", and they were asked to think about times when they felt lovable _and_ times when they were not lovable). Interestingly, when people who had low self esteem thought about times when the statement was true _and_ times when statement was not true, they actually had better mood, slightly higher self-esteem, and were happier than people who only thought of the positive statement.

The authors of the study wrote: "positive self-statements have more impact on people with low self-esteem than on people with high self-esteem, and that the impact on people with low self-esteem is negative [...] positive self-statements are especially likely to backfire for the very people they are meant to benefit: people with low self-esteem."

What struck me about this study was how much positive self statements and their relationship to the person resemble the Law. It's not a perfect parallel, and the study was not written (nor is it intended to be read) as an illustration of the Law. But just as positive self-statements (which are supposed to increase self esteem) backfire with people who need it the most, the Law (which is supposed increase obedience) also backfire on people who need to, but are not obeying the Law.

(Article citation: Wood, J. V., Perunovic, W. Q. E., & Lee, J. W. (2009). Positive self-statements: Power for some, peril for others. Psychological Science, 20, 860-866.)

Labels: , ,

5.07.2009

Felicia Day on flossing


Felicia Day's recent tweet:
When the teeth cleaning lady tells me I need to floss more, it makes me feel like a chastised 5 year old. I want to NOT floss because of it.

(Felicia Day starred in Dr. Horrible's Singalong Blog and was one of the potential slayers in Buffy the Vampire Slayer. Her tweet captures the essence of the Law - it tells you what to do, but makes you not want to do it!)

Labels: , ,

4.15.2009

Joss Whedon on Humanism and Its Enemy

Joss Whedon (creator of the incredible Buffy the Vampire Slayer, Angel, Firefly, and Dollhouse) recently received the Outstanding Lifetime Achievement Award in Cultural Humanism from the Harvard Humanist Society, and delivered an interesting address at Memorial Church at Harvard. Here's a snippet of it, but the most interesting part is the last 20 odd seconds, in which this quotation is heard:
The enemy of humanism is not faith; the enemy of humanism is hate, is fear, is ignorance, is the darker part of man that is in every humanist, every person, in the world. That is the thing we have to fight. Faith is somethig we have to embrace. Faith in God is believing absolutely in something with no proof whatsoever. Faith in humanity means believing absolutely in something with a huge amount of proof to the contrary.




I agree with some parts of Joss' point. He considers the "dark part of man" to be the enemy of humanism. And every person has this dark part inside of them. I don't disagree that there is evil inside all of us (we call it peccator). What I am surprised (and a bit confused, to be honest) by is why he would still put his faith in humanism if the enemy of humanism is in every person, including every humanist?

I don't want to put words in his mouth, but I am guessing that Joss means he would put his faith in the goodness, selflessness, creativity, beauty, intelligence, quest for knowledge that are also in every human being. I don't disagree with him in believing that we are also these things. I just happen to believe that such good things come from God (James 1:17). So if I believe that the good that is in me comes from God, obviously I would put my faith in God, rather than the good that is in me. If one denied the existence of God but still believed in the validity of human goodness, then humanism is a good belief system to hold. But if it is true that the enemy of humanism is in every person and in every humanist, then aren't humanists putting their faith in a battleground where the enemy still lurks?

I guess humanists would consider faith in humanity (in the battle ground) to be better than faith in what Joss calls the "sky bully". There is a sense that belief in humanity - in all its complexity and messiness - is much more sophisticated and much more realistic. Afterall Joss calls humanity "a huge amount of proof", and calls God the "sky bully looking down on us telling us what we're supposed to do". But I think our view is equally complex - look how many conversations we devote on just what it means to be simul iustus et peccator! It's not simplistic to have faith in God. It's just as complex and complicated, if not even more so, because there's an added variable - GOD. It's not just us making sense of our messy lives; what does it mean for our lives to be messy and complicated when we believe in and follow a good, loving, merciful, formidable God? What does it mean for us to still have both good and bad inside of us when we also claim to believe that we have been forgiven of our sins, saved by Jesus and washed as white as snow? I personally think that's a MUCH more interesting question for us to encounter and live out than a humanist approach!

Labels: , , ,

3.05.2009

On Self Control (Pt 1)

An article in the most recent edition of The Observer (the magazine put out by the Association of Psychological Science) called "Resisting Temptation" summarizes some of the most interesting research in psychology. Here are a couple of excerpts:

One of the main limits on willpower, though, turns out to be...willpower. Exerting self-control in one domain makes it harder to exert self-control in another, at least right away.

In a study led by APS Fellow Roy Baumeister (Florida State University), a group of hungry participants was forbidden from eating freshly baked cookies sitting on a plate in front of them and made to eat radishes instead. These paticipants gave up faster on a subsequent frustrating task than did a control group who had been freely allowed to indulge their sweet tooth (Baumeister, Bratslavsky, Muraven, & Tice, 1998). And in a study led by Mark Muraven (SUNY-Albany), participants made to suppress all thoughts of a white bear for five minutes consumed more beer afterwards in a "taste test" than did those in a control group, even though they knew they would subsequently be taking a driving test (Muraaven, Collins, & Nienhaus, 2002).

Numerous variants of this paradigm -- making a group of participants exercise restraint in one situation and then comparing their performance with tha t of a control group in a subsequent self-control task -- have shown the same pattern: Self-control is a limited resource that can be drained through exertion (Baumeister, Vohs, & Tice, 2007). Baumeister and colleagues call this fatigued state "ego-depletion," and it is a significant discovery because it explains why many of our specific willpower failures occur when our strength has been taxed by other self-control demands. Refraining from blowing-up at one's boss during the day may make it hard to resist a big meal of comfort food that evening. The constant effort of sticking to a diet may cause us to make more impulsive purchases at the mall.

The muscle that controls willpower does much more than just keep our impulses in check. It is part of a larger set of executive functions involved in self-monitoring, coping with stressors, weighing alternatives, and making decisisons, all of which draw on the same energy source.

It is even possible to become ego-depleted by watching other people exert willpower...Exercising vicarious self-contrrol led people to be willing to spend more on the consumer goods, as compared with a control group (Ackerman, Goldstein, Shapiro, & Bargh, in press).


A couple of weeks ago JAZ posted on Malcolm Gladwell's take on America's 'rugged idealism' - the American Dream required a sense of self-sufficiency, self-reliance, and self-control. But does it really work? My take (and you may disagree) on this is that the more we try to control ourselves and do the right thing (i.e., following the Law), the more we fail at subsequent attempts to control ourselves (i.e., transgressions are not decreased). In fact, the harder we try to exert self control, the more we will fail because of ego-depletion - we only have so much (or so little!) of willpower to begin with! It seems to ring true with Paul's words: "Where there is no law there is no transgression" (Romans 4:15) - where you don't have to exercise self control (no ego-depletion), there is no subsequent failure in exercising self control!

In my next post we'll talk about the possibility of increasing self-control...Is it possible?!?!?!!

Labels: , , ,

2.08.2009

Whedon show "Dollhouse" premiers on Feb 13

Joss Whedon's new show, "Dollhouse", premieres in 5 days! Needless to say, Simeon and I will be trying to Hulu/Tudou/TVLinks this...

Joss Whedon, creator of the immensely awesome and successful Buffy the Vampire Slayer and Angel, is back with this new science-fiction show. Here's the synopsis from Wikipedia
In Dollhouse, Eliza Dushku plays a young woman named Echo, a member of a group of people known as "Actives" or "Dolls." The Dolls have had their personalities wiped clean so they can be imprinted with any number of new personas, including memory, muscle memory, skills, and language, for different assignments. They're then hired out for particular jobs, crimes, fantasies, and occasional good deeds. On missions, Actives are monitored internally (and remotely) by Handlers. In between tasks, they are mind-wiped into a child-like state and live in a futuristic dormitory/laboratory, a hidden facility nicknamed "The Dollhouse". The story follows Echo, who begins, in her mind-wiped state, to become self-aware.

Beyond Dushku's character, the show will also revolve around the people who run the mysterious "Dollhouse" and two other "Dolls", Victor and Sierra, who are friendly with Echo. Although the Actives are ostensibly volunteers, the operation is highly illegal and under constant threat on one end from Paul Ballard, a determined federal agent who has heard a rumor about the Dolls, and an insane rogue Active on the other.


If you've liked Whedon shows (Buffy, Angel, Firefly) in the past, you will know that he often uses his shows to illustrate philosophical/sociological/psychological issues. This show is set to explore questions about what constitutes the 'self', and I am really looking forward to see how Whedon deals with issues of the self through this show. And don't worry, I'll be trying as best as I can to take illustrations from this show for our talk at the MBird Conference on "Grace and the self".

Labels: , ,

12.26.2008

A quick quote on spiritual transformation

...I am convinced that most of our ministries have legitimated the autonomous self and even fortified it with all kinds of religious armour. Religious people are even harder to transform because they don't think they need it.

Richard Rohr, "The Enneagram: A Christian Perspective" (p. xv)

Merry Christmas!

Labels: , ,

9.16.2008

Luther Probably Ate His Vegetables

I just read an interesting little article in the NY Times about children's diet. The article describes the woes parents face when trying to coax their kids to eat a healthy, balanced diet. It also outlined some mistakes commonly made by parents in their endeavour - here are a few quotes:
"Demanding that a child eat at least one bite of everything seems reasonable, but it’s likely to backfire. Studies show that children react negatively when parents pressure them to eat foods, even if the pressure offers a reward."

"Parents worry that children will binge on treats, so they often put them out of sight or on a high shelf. But a large body of research shows that if a parent restricts a food, children just want it more."

"The researchers found that restricting the cookies had a profound effect: consumption more than tripled compared with when the cookies were served on plates. Other studies show that children whose food is highly restricted at home are far more likely to binge when they have access to forbidden foods."

Who knew that one reason kids don't eat the things grown-ups want them to is due to the same theological principle that we now understand as The Law?

As a side note: when I visited my family in Hong Kong, I personally witnessed my cousin's two-year-old eat chicken's feet, spinach, and pretty much everything else that we put on his plate. It was pretty incredible.

Labels: , , , ,

9.02.2008

You Can't Hurry God

Lately I've been listening to a bunch of American classical folk music that I used to perform when I was part of a touring music group back in the (gasp) 90's. One of the songs on repeat in my playlist is one I'd learned from Peter and Mary Alice Amidon, called "You Can't Hurry God" (listen to a sample of it here). The chorus, which I think is really awesome and want to share with you, goes:

You can’t hurry God, no, you just have to wait
You gotta trust him and give him time, child, no matter how long it takes
He’s a God you can’t hurry, but he’ll be there, don’t you worry
You know he may not come when you want him, but he’s right on time

I particularly like the last line: He may not come when you want him, but he's right on time. Somehow that captures both a) my impatience when I have to wait on God, and b) God's loving nature towards me by coming right on time.

Here's an awesome performance of it by Mahalia Jackson:

Labels: , ,

8.03.2008

The Gospel According To Pixar I: Wall-E

(Warning: Post contains spoilers, so don't read it unless you want to find out about scenes from the movie.)

I went to see Wall-E last week, and despite hearing numerous "You're going to love it!" from different folks I was still amazed by the movie. After creating some of the animated films I've most enjoyed in recent years, Pixar yet again blew my mind.

You can read about the plot of the story here, so I won't go into that in detail. The movie touched me for several reasons. One is the portrayal of one-way love from Wall-E to Eve. When she shuts down on earth due to completion of her probe for life on earth, Wall-E is a) not certain of whether Eve is even interested in him, although he might not have been sophisticated enough to consider the possibilities, and b) gives up his time, his mission, etc., to protect her. It sounds simple (maybe also simplistic), but I like how one-way love is simple. Wall-E, though sentient, is most likely not sophisticated enough to evaluate whether his gestures would ever be reciprocated. All he knows is that he likes Eve and wants to protect her. I like this picture of one way love and how it resonates with me; when portrayed in ways children can understand, it doesn't seem to have to "make sense" in grown-up terms, but it's just the way it is.

Another part of the story which I loved is how Eve, having become aware of what Wall-E was doing for her (through watching the video that recorded Wall-E's protective gestures towards her while she was shut down and inactive on earth, and having observed his persistence in ensuring the safety of the little plant, which he gave to her and was the reason that her directive was complete), realizes Wall-E's love. Not fully realizing what had happened, she begins to reciprocate. She doesn't really quite realize what's going on either; Wall-E is nowhere as sophisticated as she is as a robot, and what's really on her mind is her directive (to deliver the little plant to where it belongs). But somehow, she comes to understand (probably pre-consciously) what love is, and responds by being willing to give up her mission. I like this picture of love inspiring response from Eve, even before she was really aware of it; and it's Wall-E's love that inspires to be willing to give up the most important thing to her: which is her mission.

The third thing I really loved about Wall-E is how he is a little like a messiah figure (though that might be stretching it)--here's why. Everything that Wall-E touches becomes better. He shows another robot how to wave. Because of Wall-E, two humans actually begin to communicate with each other. He frees a bunch of broken, malfunctioning (though benign) robots and they follow him - and they help him. Out of love for Eve, Wall-E even sacrifices himself in order to ensure the success of her directive. He was crushed because of the robots who could not stop following previously given orders. Wall-E changed things and shook the paradigm a little bit like the way Jesus did.

And last, but not least, THE ANIMATION IS INCREDIBLE! I love the minmalist dialogue (mostly robotic sounds from the robots), and the sequence in space was just stunning. (Also, Wall-E reminds me a little of ET, probably because of the big eyes and long neck.) Also, he looks REAL. Here's a little blurb from the Wikipedia article about the creation of Wall-E:

After directing Finding Nemo, [Andrew] Stanton felt they "had really achieved the physics of believing you were really under water, so I said 'Hey, let’s do that with air'. Let’s fix our lenses, let’s get the depth of field looking exactly how anamorphic lenses work and do all these tricks that make us have the same kind of dimensionality that we got on Nemo with an object out in the air and on the ground'". Producer Jim Morris added that the film was animated so that it would feel "as if there really was a cameraman". Dennis Muren was hired to advise Pixar on replicating science fiction films from the 1960s and 1970s, including elements such as 70 mm frames, barrel distortion and lens flare."

Wall-E is up there along with the Chronicles of Riddick as one of my favourite movies of all time.

Labels: , , , , ,

6.23.2008

The Illusion of Conscious Will (Quotes from Ch. 1)


One thing that fascinates me is the contrast between implicit (or un/sub/pre-conscious cognition of which we are unaware) and explicit cognition (the thoughts that we are actually aware of having), and the relationship between these two types of cognition to our behaviour and how we actually live our lives. I've been reading a really fascinating book by Dan Wegner, a professor of psychology at Harvard, called The Illusion of Conscious Will. I'm not through reading the book yet (actually, I'm only on chapter 3!), but some of the quotes were fascinating and I thought I would share them here. [I've added some commentary of my own--BPZ]

People have a tendency to think that the cause for any voluntary action is their consciously willing the action, but this is not the case. The book's key point is that the thing that we call "conscious will" which drives our actions and behaviour, is actually not a causal force, but "an illusion". Wegner points out that what we know as "conscious will" - the apparent conscious decision that we make to do or engage in something - is psychologically and biologically distinct from how the mind actually creates action. For example, it is scientifically well documented that people's voluntary action first begins with brain activity, then the conscious awareness of the will, then action--meaning that the conscious will followed, not preceded, the brain activity that prompted action.

"It usually seems that we consciously will our voluntary actions, but this is an illusion." (p. 1)

"One might assume that the experience of consciously willing an action and the causation of the action by the person's conscious mind are the same thing. As it turns out, however, they are entirely distinct, and the tendency to confuse them is the source of the illusion of conscious will that this book is about." (p. 3)

"Will is a feeling. David Hume [...] proposed to define the will in this way, as "nothing but the internal impression we feel and are conscious of, when we knowingly give rise to any new motion for our body, or new perception of our mind" (1739, p. 399)." (p. 3)

"Apparently, we cannot yet trace the experience of wil to any particular signal in the nervous system--from brain to body, or from body to brain [...] It appears that the experience of will occurs through a system that presents the idea of a volntary action to consciousness and also produces the action. The idea can occur just in advance of the action, as when people are allowed to act a lib, or the idea may come to mind just after the action, as when people are prompted to act rapidly. People get the experience of will primarily when the idea of acting occurs to them before they act." (p. 60)

So why do people have this experience of the conscious will? Wegner draws from research about how people make inferences about cause an effect to answer this question. Basically, people will infer causality when things happen within a specific window of time. For example, if you hit a billiard ball and it moves to hit another billiard ball just before the second ball moved, you would probably infer that ball 1 caused ball 2 to move. But if ball 2 moved before ball 1 touched it, or if there was movement long after the two billiard balls touched, then you might not infer that ball 1 caused ball 2 to move. People also seem to infer causality when the effect resembles its (perceived) cause. For example, if you came to my house for dinner and the food was terrible, and you also knew that I was a bad cook, you might infer that I made dinner. (For the record, I'm a relatively good cook!)


"The unique human convenience of conscious thoughts that preview our actions gives us the privilege of feeling we willfully cause what we do. In fact, however, unconscious and inscrutable mechanisms create both conscious thought about action and the action, and also produce the sense of will we experience by perceiving the thought as cause of the action. So, while our thoughts may have deep, important, and unconscious causal connections to our actions, the experience of conscious will arises from a process that interprets these connections, not from the connections themselves." (p. 98)

Ethics, philosophy and religion put a premium on the conscious will as a determinant of personal responsibility--if you didn't consciously will something, you couldn't be held (entirely) responsible. Wegner's book and these findings about the illusion of conscious will may have immense bearings on what we know about the things that we consider part of our everyday lives. The Bible also talks a lot about making our thoughts captive to Christ (e.g., 2 Cor 10:5), assuming that conscious thought is the cause for our behaviour. I can't count the number of times I've consciously willed myself to not think about something, only to find ourselves thinking about the same thing 3 seconds later. I've also lost count of the number of times I've consciously willed myself to not do something, but do it anyway (e.g., Romans 7). I'll leave you with a few things to ponder: There's a disconnect between our conscious will and action. If we don't consciously will our actions, are we still responsible for them? How does this influence our understanding of our sin(s)? More importantly, how does this influence our understanding of grace-enabled action and transformation?

Labels: , , ,