12.28.2010

That's Christmas!

With Christmas now upon us, something I posted last year that (for me at least) sets the right mood for the season:


That's Christmas! from St Helen’s Church on Vimeo.

Labels: ,

12.17.2010

C. S. Lewis on The Nativity


Among the oxen (like an ox I’m slow)
I see a glory in the stable grow
Which, with the ox’s dullness might at length
Give me an ox’s strength.

Among the asses (stubborn I as they)
I see my Savior where I looked for hay;
So may my beastlike folly learn at least
The patience of a beast.

Among the sheep (I like a sheep have strayed)
I watch the manger where my Lord is laid;
Oh that my baa-ing nature would win thence
Some woolly innocence.

Labels: , ,

11.26.2010

Mini-Conference Recordings - HAPPY THANKSGIVING!

Again, an enormous and very heartfelt Mockingbird thank you to everyone who helped out with last weekend's mini-conference in Pensacola! In particular, Jeff & Kerry Hual and the Christ Church Pensacola staff. We are so thankful for how it all went.

Links to the recordings of the presentations are below. If you find them to be helpful (and you were not able to attend the conference in person), we ask that you *consider* making a donation to help cover the cost of putting it on. In fact, do so and as a token of our appreciation, we'll send you the audio files of Dr. Zahl's fantastic/invaluable pre-conference Preaching Seminar. Enjoy:

Talk 1. Grace Again (and Again) Part 1 - Dr. Paul Zahl
Talk 2. Grace Again (and Again) Part 2 - Dr. Paul Zahl
Closing Sermon. The Advantages of a Weak Resume - John Zahl




Labels: , , , , , , , , , ,

9.28.2010

A Mini-Conference Preview (Part 1 - Everybody Hurts... Sometimes)

With the upcoming Mockingbird Mini-Conference only fifty days away (!) I wanted to start a series of posts familiarizing everyone with the conference theme and why we chose it, sort of a preview of what my talk will entail, and one that I'm hoping will grab you (and convince you to register ASAP).

I've come to understand in my own life that the deep substratum that trumps all other categories of human identity is suffering. We all suffer. And this conference seeks to reach people on that level. Let me explain:

One morning last Spring, a member of my Sunday school class came up to me after class with a pointed question. He said, "I understand all that you're saying, but it still doesn't answer a pressing question that weighs on my heart: why does God allow suffering?"

And I did what most of us would probably do when faced with that question. I immediately launched into a very logical, cogent theological argument. And by the time I made it to my car I was kicking myself, because I knew that I had handled it the wrong way.

When a person asks a question like, “why do we suffer,” or “why does God allow suffering,” that person is asking a question of the heart. And a question of the heart is a question born out of feelings, not out of rational thought. So a rational, logical answer won’t work. It can’t get past the heart’s defenses and speak to a person where he or she is suffering.

And so this Mini-Conference theme is an attempt to speak to the heart from the heart. For my part, I'm going to use some of my own experiences with suffering to speak not from the head, but from the heart. And I want to start laying the groundwork for this by establishing the premise that suffering is universal. I came to understand this in a very unexpected way years ago.

My grandfather died in 1992. It was my first experience with suffering and grief. I was 22 at the time and was working at a college job in a steel fabrication shop. On this particular morning at work, the secretary called me to the office because my mother was on the phone. She had telephoned to tell me that my grandfather had died instantly of a heart attack that morning and was alone on his daily walk when he died.
[CONTINUE READING]

Labels: , , , , ,

9.10.2010

NOV 19&20! God's Grace When We Need It Most: The Gospel For Hard Times

This November 19th and 20th, please join us at Christ Church in Pensacola, Florida, together with our special guest, The Rev. Dr. Paul F. M. Zahl, as we take an in-depth look at how God’s Grace can find us and transform us even in the midst of difficult and trying times.

This mini-conference takes the same approach as this blog (hopefully!): accessible to both believer and nonbeliever alike, culturally-engaged, theologically passionate, and, despite the heavy subject matter, fun! We also anticipate that it will be a time of extraordinary warmth, humor and fellowship - a great opportunity to reconnect with old friends and meet some new ones. If you can't wait until our annual NYC conference in the Spring, this is your chance!

Dr. Zahl will be giving two talks: Revisiting the Gospel Message: Grace Again and Connecting with the Gospel in and Through the Culture Around Us. John Zahl will speak about Grace in Addiction; David Browder will treat us to The Theology on the Cross with Meat on the Bones (and Horseradish on the Side); and I'll be on hand to present Broken on the Wheels of Living: Grace in Suffering.

AND DON'T MISS THIS! In addition to the main conference, Dr. Zahl is leading a special "pre-conference seminar" on preaching during the day on Friday. Even if you're not a preacher, it's going to be amazing. Come if you can.

The cost to attend the main conference is $65 ($85 after November 1) which includes dinner Friday and lunch Saturday; The cost to attend Dr. Zahl's preaching pre-conference during the day on Friday is $75 ($95 after November 1) which includes lunch; The cost to attend both the main conference and the preaching pre-conference is $120 ($150 after November 1) which includes lunch and dinner on Friday and lunch on Saturday. The deadline to register is November 15. Childcare is available.

Follow This Link For More Information.

Follow This Link To Register.

Labels: , , , , , , ,

9.03.2010

Leon Morris on The Atonement

"We ought to be quite clear that no full and final theory of the atonement has yet been given and that this is not simply because we have not yet been fortunate enough to hit on the right solution. It is because we are not good enough as men and not profound enough as thinkers ever to get to the bottom of the subject. The problem is too big for us. Our minds cannot take in at once and the same time all the complexities involved.

"But the problem is not only a mental one. It is salutary to reflect that those who understand the atonement best seem not necessarily to be great scholars (though some are). They are rather those who have suffered deeply and who are sufficiently pure of heart to see God. We will need H. R. Mackintosh's reminder that the basic reason why we do not understand the atonement is that we are not good enough.

-Leon Morris, The Cross in the New Testament (Eerdmans, 1965)

Labels: ,

9.01.2010

SAVE THE DATE! Pensacola Mini-Conference November 19/20

Looking for a warm weather retreat this Fall?! I'm very pleased to announce that the second annual Mockingbird Mini-Conference at Christ Church in Pensacola, Florida will take place on November 19-20, 2010. Our primary speaker will be Dr. Paul F. M. Zahl, with a number of other, to-be-announced Mockingbird contributors also on tap to make presentations. Not to be missed!

Plans are in the works for Dr. Zahl to host a pre-conference seminar/workshop on preaching during the day on Friday the 19th, with the main conference taking place Friday evening and through the day on Saturday the 20th.


More details, including topics and themes as well as pricing and registration, will be posted as soon as things are finalized. Everyone is warmly invited. We are really excited about this. 

For the recordings of last year's mini-conference, click here.

Labels: , , , , ,

8.16.2010

I Hate Graveyards And Old Pawnshops

I saw some sad news a while back. Evidently the Roy Rogers and Dale Evans museum has closed and the owners recently auctioned off all of the memorabilia, including Roy's (taxidermied) horse Trigger and dog Bullet (I'm glad they didn't stuff Dale, too!).

Rogers wasn't an icon of my generation, but with the advent of cable television and a lack of programming to fill the available time slots, suddenly the wild west was riding through the living room of my childhood. I loved
The Lone Ranger, The Cisco Kid, and Wanted Dead or Alive, as well as the great old westerns starring John Wayne, Roy Rogers and the like.

And I suppose that as the remaining vestiges of Rogers' generation ride off into the sunset of life, there isn't much traffic at the museum anymore. But it's sad to see what's left of the King of Cowboys--his boots and hats, his famous stuffed mount--ride off into the sunset of memory. It reminds me of the transitory nature of our lives, and how that stands in stark, incontrovertible contrast to God's eternity.

Have you ever tried to grasp eternity? Hendrik Von Loon once tried to write an adequate description of eternity in the introduction of his book, “The History of Mankind”, and this is what he wrote:


[CONTINUE READING]

Labels: , , , ,

8.03.2010

Stiffelio, Cards From Another World, and A Great Eucatastrophe

Earlier this summer, Mockingbird recommended an 1850 Verdi opera entitled Stiffelio. If you managed to catch this on DVD, you were no doubt confronted as I was with a theme as old as the Gospel, a theme that is the Gospel: the theme of our brokenness and God's unmerited favor reaching out to us in that brokenness in order to rescue us.

Stiffelio deals with the infidelity of a pastor's wife, the pastor's subsequent discovery of it, and the way in which forgiveness unfolds, which comes in a way that could only be from God.

The most crushing scene takes place in the church's cemetery, illuminated only by the moon and a warm swath of light from within the church, a light which is streaming through a single stained glass window. On the window is a simple image of the Cross.

As the scene unfolds, for me it brought to mind a sermon title from Paul Zahl, his Easter 2009 sermon entitled "Cards from Another World", which was a Bob Dylan reference. It's a line from the song "Series of Dreams", in which he says, The cards are no good that your holding, unless they're from another world.

Now, what do I mean by bringing up this Dylan lyric? Well, the cards that we as humankind are holding, in the absence of an intervention from outside, literally from outside of this world, ie., Christ--these cards are no good. The hand of cards that we're holding as members of fallen humanity will only and always lead us to trouble in a never-ending cycle of hurt.

And we see these cards for Stiffelio the pastor and Lina his straying wife play out in grave detail. Just look at what Lina says when she is alone in the cemetery at the beginning of the scene:

My crime is written on every tomb, at every murmur of the breeze I hear the voice of judgment. (Looking down) This is my mother’s grave. She was so pure…and I? Mother, help me in my sorrow! (She throws herself down on her mother’s tomb.) Look down from the throne of heaven on your daughter’s sorrow. Offer the Lord these penitent tears. Weep for me with the Saints. Then God will not deny me his forgiveness.

So these are the cards that Lina is holding: shame, guilt, fear of impending judgment--a whole slew of negative emotions come to mind. Those are just a few.

A little later Stiffelio discovers that the rumors are true, and he finds that he is confronting his wife's lover face to face. The man is on his knees in the cemetery before Stiffelio, who brandishes a sword over his head and says these words:
[CONTINUE READING]

Labels: , , , , , ,

7.21.2010

Speaking of Thornton Wilder...

The great author expressing a similar sentiment as the one which inspires PZ's new DVD (below), slightly elucidated, and touching on some of Mockingbird's core concerns. This comes from the final paragraph of the foreward to his book of short plays The Angel That Troubled The Waters:

"The last four plays here were written within a year and a half. Almost all the plays in this book are religious, but religious in that dilute fashion that is a believer's concession to a contemporary standard of good manners. But these four plant their flag as boldly as they may. It is the kind of work that I would like to do well, in spite of the fact that there has seldom been an age in literature when such a vein was less welcome and less understood. I hope, through many mistakes, to discover the spirit that is not unequal to the elevation of the great religious themes, yet which does not fall into a repellent didacticism. Didacticism is an attempt at the coercion of another's free mind, even though one knows that in these matters beyond logic, beauty is the only persuasion. Here the schoolmaster enters again. He sees all that is fairest in the Christian tradition made repugnant to the new generations by reason of the diction in which it is expressed. The intermittent sincerity of generations of clergymen and teachers have rendered embarrassing and even ridiculous the terms of the spiritual life. Nothing succeeds in dampening the aspirations of the young to-day--who dares use the word "aspiration" without enclosing it, knowingly, in quotation-marks?--like the names they hear given to them. The revival of religion is almost a matter of rhetoric. The work is difficult, perhaps impossible (perhaps all religions die out with the exhaustion of language), but it at least reminds us that Our Lord asked us in His work to be not only gentle as doves, but as wise as serpents."

The Davis House
Lawrenceville, N.J.
June, 1928.

Labels: , , ,

7.09.2010

Strange Warning Label...

I found this book (with it's curious warning label) yesterday at Books-A-Million:

Could this be a reaction to a rash of returns from unwary Protestants? Did those Protestants list "Didn't know it was a Catholic book" as the reason for return?

Or could it be something more disquieting than the merely comical: could it be that because of the currently blurred focus of the modern evangelical movement, a title like "The Imitation of Christ" just seems to fit right in with "What Would Jesus Do", such that the message of evangelicals has now become utterly vague and indistinguishable.

At any rate, I wasn't aware that anyone needed to be warned that The Imitation of Christ by Thomas a Kempis is "Catholic" (the title AND the author would seem to give that away), but I would love to have a roll of "Heretical" warning stickers and an afternoon to use them on some of the other selections on that same aisle (which includes plenty of Osteen and McLaren, but not any Zahl).

Do any of you frequent used bookstores? I love to peruse their religion aisles because I find it's a great way to find out which heresies du jour are losing popularity. A while back the "Prayer of Jaebez" was piling up, and lately "The Celestine Prophecy" and "The Purpose Driven Life" have done the same thing. Would anyone care to guess which might be the next "religious" book that will find itself relegated to the used book aisles en masse? Perhaps Osteen, or maybe McLaren...

Labels: , , , ,

Mary Karr Discusses "Lit"

This one comes to us by way of MB contributor Emily. I think it's safe to say that Mary Karr is a fellow Mockingbird, whether she knows it yet or not! Her life story reminds me of another MB favorite, Brennan Manning (author of "The Ragamuffin Gospel"), of whom it's been said that the Lord allowed him to walk through dark valleys so that he could later lead others to the Light.

Labels: , , , ,

7.08.2010

A Creative Way To Thwart The First Use Of The Law...

There were times this little trick would have been helpful in downtown Birmingham, Alabama as well (say, around 20th Street and 6th Avenue North!):




Everyone must submit himself to the governing authorities, for there is no authority except that which God has established.
(Romans 13:1)

Labels: , ,

Show and Tell...


I took this picture the other evening and thought it so breathtaking I just wanted to share it. This is sunset over Perdido Bay in Northwest Florida:


Ever since the creation of the world his eternal power and divine nature, invisible though they are, have been understood and seen through the things he has made...(Romans 1:20)

Labels: , ,

7.02.2010

You Want Me To Do...What?

There are two messages coming from some pulpits today that I personally don't like. I'm sure there are plenty of things being said from plenty of pulpits that could be addressed, but these two things have become so ubiquitous that I'm simply fed up, and feel I must say something.

The first of these is the admonition to "live into my baptismal vows." The other is the admonition to "see Jesus Christ in the face of 'the other'." I'll deal with the first one here, and the other one at a later date.

So you want me to live into my baptismal vows? Wow, that sounds like a great idea! One hitch though: how am I supposed to do that?

Now, granted, in the Episcopal liturgy those who are about to be baptized make certain vows (and the congregation present renews those vows) to renounce evil, turn to Christ, etc., etc. Here's the rub, though: in making each vow, we all say, "I will, with God's help," the point being, of course, that I have absolutely no chance of fulfilling these things that I'm promising to do without the work of God within me.

If I wake up in the morning and say, "Today I think I will live into my baptismal vows," I'm doomed to failure. I will come home that evening sorrowing, because all I will have achieved is a troubled conscience that points out to me each and every time I failed to do that which I vowed to do. Besides, that isn't really the point of my baptism, is it?

No, the point of baptism is not my promises to God, it's God's promise to me: the promise that through baptism I am accepted as God's own, sealed with Christ in his death, and raised with Christ to a new and everlasting life. That's God's promise to me that is sealed in my baptism.


I'm reminded of two Old Testament examples that speak to this matter. The first of these is God's handling of Moses and the Israelites. After Moses had received the ten commandments and come down from the mountain, he presented God's Law to the Israelites. Then they sacrificed young bulls, Moses sprinkled the people with the blood of the sacrifice, and the people vowed, "All this we will do." And we know how that turned out! They failed at every turn. And that's what "living into my baptismal vows" looks like. The Israelites never managed to follow the Law, and I can't do it, either.

The other Old Testament example, the one that points to what baptism is really about, is that of God's covenant with Abraham. After God made his covenant with Abraham, he told him to make sacrifices, and Abraham split the animals in two, after which God's spirit passed between the halves, thereby sealing God's promise in blood. So with Abraham, it wasn't him saying "All this I will do," it was God promising what he would do for Abraham.


That's what Baptism looks like. It's not my vow to God, it's his vow, his promise to me. And like God's promise to Abraham, his promise to me is sealed in blood, the blood of Christ shed on Calvary. That's the blood sacrifice that seals this promise of the new covenant. That's what I am sealed into with my baptism. And that's where my only real hope lies.

So, please, you folks who ascend the pulpit Sunday by Sunday, take note: if you're going to tell me to live into my baptismal vows, I might as well stay home. Failure is the only possible outcome of that errand. Instead, tell me the good news about what God has done for me, which is symbolized and sealed by my baptism, and for that I will gladly show up every Sunday!

Labels: , , ,

6.29.2010

O Lost, And By The Winds Grieved



Human suffering is an important touchstone for much of what is discussed here at Mockingbird. And as a native Pensacolian watching oil wash up on our shores every day, I am seeing suffering in my own life and in the lives of my family and friends on a scale that I had never before imagined.

As a result of this daily assault, my mind keeps turning back to some points that Steven Paulson made at the 2009 Mockingbird Conference which touch on the source of human suffering.

Dr. Paulson pointed out that long ago, Saint Augustine observed that we are more where we love than where we live. Anyone who has experienced a long distance relationship knows what this is like. Before long, your thoughts and everything else about you starts going in the direction of where the other person is.

So Augustine observed that in such a situation the heart is no longer where it is geographically located, because it’s grabbing and holding on somewhere else. And where the heart is grabbing and holding is where we truly are. It’s where we live.

From this observation, Augustine asserted that the heart is essentially a love machine, that it creates love and thereby defines us and shapes our lives. And this was so well received that it’s part of where we get the association even to this day of romantic love being born out of the heart instead of the head: the idea of the heart being the source of all love.

But Martin Luther made a brilliant observation during his lifetime, one that corrected Augustine. Luther observed that the heart is not so much a love machine. It’s a hope machine. And what you’re hoping for in life is where you actually live.

In Luther’s observation, what happens when two people fall in love is that their individual hopes for the future come together in such a way that it forms a common hope. That’s what love is, it’s a common hope in one another, a hope that the other person will be there tomorrow, and the next day, that a common life will be formed, one that will last. And love dies when those individual hopes no longer form a common hope. One or the other changes his or her mind, doesn’t want marriage, or children, or what have you.

So the heart is always hoping for the future, and when it finds that it has the thing it loves, it hopes to have this thing forever into the future. And so we live our lives constantly encircling ourselves with our hopes for the future so that they are what we see. And these hopes are where we live. These hopes are what get us through our day.

And so I've come to understand that suffering is a natural result of this functioning of the heart as hope machine. Suffering comes out of things that are hoped for being cut off. We all hope for a long life, and we suffer when the doctor tells us we have an exit date scheduled, and it’s soon. We all hope to have our loved ones with us forever, and we suffer greatly when they are taken from us. All suffering is a kind of cutting off—it’s a reversal of hope.

And life for us here on the Gulf Coast has become an enormous reversal of hope, because we have built our lives and our economy on the fragile beauty of this place, and we have placed our hopes for the future in the assumption that this place's beauty would endure forever. As a community, almost in the same breath together, we have come to realize that this hope has been cut off and taken from us. So we are all struggling to come to grips with this new reality, and we are suffering as a result.

Recently the rector of Christ Church Pensacola had the opportunity to ask a question of Presiding Bishop Katherine Jefferts Schori. He asked her in her opinion as a scientist (prior to becoming a priest, she was an oceanographer), how long will it take for the Gulf to recover to what it was prior to the spill?

She replied, "Not in our lifetimes, Neal. Probably not in our children's lifetimes, but maybe in our grand children's."

How do I explain this to my seven-year-old son: that the Gulf where he and Daddy love to play and fish is probably certainly gone for Daddy's lifetime, and may be for his lifetime as well? How do we file a claim for the dashed hopes we must now live with and the memories we will never have?

I'm reminded of a passage from Thomas Wolfe's Look Homeward Angel in which the author himself appears to be remembering something from his own past, in this case the love of a young girl, a hope which for him must have been cut off in such a way that caused him great suffering:


Come up into the hills, O my young love. Return! O lost, and by the wind grieved, ghost, come back again, as first I knew you in the timeless valley, where we shall feel ourselves anew, bedded on magic in the month of June. There was a place where all the sun went glistening in your hair, and from the hill we could have put a finger on a star. Where is the day that melted into one rich noise? Where the music of your flesh, the rhyme of your teeth, the dainty languor of your legs, your small firm arms, your slender fingers, to be bitten like an apple, and the little cherry-teats of your white breasts? And where are all the tiny wires of finespun maidenhair? Quick are the mouths of earth, and quick the teeth that fed upon this loveliness. You who were made for music, will hear music no more: in your dark house the winds are silent. Ghost, ghost, come back from that marriage that we did not foresee, return not into life, but into magic, where we have never died, into the enchanted wood, where we still lie strewn on the grass. Come up into the hills, O my young love: return. O lost, and by the wind grieved, ghost, come back again.

Labels: , , , , ,

6.25.2010

Sinners Welcome

Mary Karr was recently interviewed by Religion & Ethics News Weekly:

Labels: , , ,

5.19.2010

Bart Ehrman and the Rashomon Effect

I recently caught part of the March 31 debate between Bart Erhman and Craig Evans on the reliability of the Gospels. While listening to Dr. Ehrman drone on in his typical, dated, liberal textual criticism of the Bible, something struck me: Dr. Erhman has completely ignored the Rashomon effect.

Dr. Ehrman's argument is basic (and more than a little sophomoric): that the Gospel writers contradict each other in some of the things they record Jesus saying and doing, and so these discrepancies mean that none of the events recorded in the Gospels can be trusted. But Ehrman was apparently never exposed to Akira Kurosawa's 1950 cinematic masterpiece, Rashomon, or he would understand exactly why those discrepancies exist.

In Rashomon, a concrete event is recorded through the eyes of four different eyewitnesses (see the connection already?). The event that occurs is a crime: the murder of a man and the rape of his wife in a forest grove. As the story unfolds, each witness gives a different account of what occurred because each is drawing from his or her own human perspective.
[CONTINUE READING]

Labels: , ,

5.12.2010

Ikiru ("To Live")


Akira Kurosawa’s cinematic masterpiece, Ikiru, is a wonderful movie. Kurosawa was a mid-20th century Japanese director, and his movies are absolutely brilliant, if you can survive three hours of black and white Japanese with subtitles. If you can, you will find that his characters speak to you out of their lives at a very deep level.

The name of the movie is a clue to its subject matter. "Ikiru" means "to live", and so the movie has to do with life. In fact, it has to do with life, death, and how we deal with these issues when the doctor tells us we have an exit date scheduled and it's soon.

In Ikiru, Watanabe is a man who has worked for the government as a low level bureaucrat for 30 years, and has really done nothing with his life except go to work and come home, sleep, shave, and repeat. Then he finds out that he has stomach cancer, and only has a few months to live. And the movie doesn’t deal with his death so much as it deals with the steps of grief that he goes through in adjusting to his new reality.

At first, he sits in numb darkness. Then he is haunted by all of the “would have been, should have been, and could have been”. He finds that he has enormous regrets about his life, because for the past 30 years he has lived without living. Then he seeks solace in sake, in late night carousing, the company of women, but none of it sooths his suffering.

Finally, he meets a young woman who seems so alive to him in the effervescence of her youth, that he starts spending all of his time with her. And at one of the climactic moments in the movie, he explains to her that he wants to find out what makes her so alive, because he wants to know what it is to live with so much life at least once before he dies. And who wouldn't? It's truly touching.

But what is so sad about the movie, the 300 pound gorilla in the middle of the room, is the absence of God—the absence of a God who knows what it means to suffer and is closest to us in our suffering.
[CONTINUE READING]

Labels: , , ,

5.03.2010

Pray for our friends in Pensacola

Everyone has been watching in horror in the last few days as the expanding oil slick threatens the Gulf coast. But few people are feeling it as keenly, we feel sure, as our Mockingbird brothers and sisters in Pensacola, city of sugar-white beaches.

Their wildlife, their beautiful beaches, and their economy are at great risk.

Please keep our many MB friends there in your prayers, especially the lovely parish of Christ Church who so graciously hosted us last January in our first ever mini-conference, as well as the family of beloved MB contributor Jeff Hual.



And a couple days ago, with a melancholy discussion on the effect on the town itself:
On Pensacola Beach, fears grow with oil spill

Labels: , , ,