10.25.2010

Hoping For Superman

An article in the Smithsonian Magazine described recent evidence regarding the 1918 Romanov royal family murders during the Bolshevik revolution. The story also related that there are actually many Russians today who (after 90 years of Communism and "Democracy") want the Monarchy back.

“The monarchy is a romantic idea,” says French historian Mireille Massip, an expert on White Russian exiles. “Democracy is not popular, because democrats turned out to be total losers. Communists aren’t popular. Monarchism is seen as something fresh and fashionable.”

Despite evidence to the contrary that you should not put your hope in human leadership, we always come back to expecting human perfection and competence. But what we get are more losers.

There was only one Superman.

Labels: ,

2.15.2010

Boulder Colorado, Human Nature and the Law of Sustainability

From the Wall Street Journal, a fascinating look at the growing reaction to the Law of Sustainability - in Boulder CO of all places. I'm all for "going green" but this is pretty revealing about what's really calling the shots re: personal decision-making. Apparently intentions and reality aren't lining up exactly the way that officials thought they would, i.e. there is an increasingly awkward discrepancy (ht AL):

City officials never dreamed they'd have to play nanny when they set out in 2006 to make Boulder a role model in the fight against global warming. The cause seemed like a natural fit in a place where residents tend to be politically liberal and passionate about the great outdoors. Instead, as Congress considers how to encourage Americans to conserve more energy, Boulder stands as a cautionary tale about the limits of good intentions.

"What we've found is that for the vast majority of people, it's exceedingly difficult to get them to do much of anything," says Kevin Doran, a senior research fellow at the University of Colorado at Boulder.
---------------

Boulder has found that financial incentives and an intense publicity campaign aren't enough to spur most homeowners to action, even in a city so environmentally conscious that the college football stadium won't sell potato chips because the packaging isn't recyclable.

Take George Karakehian. He considers himself quite green: He drives a hybrid, recycles, uses energy-efficient compact fluorescent bulbs. But he refuses to practice the most basic of conservation measures: Shutting the doors to his downtown art gallery when his heating or air conditioning is running.

Mr. Karakehian knows he's wasting energy. He doesn't care. "I'm old-school," Mr. Karakehian says. "I've always been taught that an open door is the way to invite people in."

---------------

"If a place like Boulder that regards itself as being in the environmental forefront has such a tough time, these types of efforts are not going to work as a core policy" for the nation, says Roger Pielke Jr., who studies the political response to climate change at the University of Colorado, Boulder.

Labels: , , , ,

1.27.2010

Casuistry, Business trips, Rationalization, and other Barriers to the Gospel

A recent article from the WSJ described how Resorts and Hotels are dropping the word 'resort' from their names in order to attract business. As tolerance for corporate excess becomes less fashionable, companies want to 'appear' to be scaling back on business trips and conferences.

This does not mean anything about the hotel or the business trip has changed at all. It just looks better to the public. It is also another example of 'casuistry.' Casuistry is "resolving of specific cases of conscience... through interpretation of ethical principles or religious doctrine," (m-w.com). The second definition is "specious argument or rationalization."

Casuistry is making highly nuanced arguments or defenses to explain away what you know (at some level) is wrong. Casuistry is what Jesus inveighs against when speaking of the Pharisees and their traditions (Mark 7:1-13). They use reasoning with their tradition to 'outwit' the word of God.

These theological self-justifying gymnastics may get us off the hook or even makes us feel better. We all use casuistry and rationalization to give reasons why we fail to keep a diet, exercise, or give more to Haiti. But in the end they are minds games that act as barriers to the gospel. Jesus and St. Paul want our word to be enough and our yes to be yes, not just because we should be people of integrity, but because strait talk is honest talk. And honest talk puts the focus on us which takes our sin into account (Mk7:14-23). And awareness of sin leads directly to the sweet sound of forgiveness. There is no better destination than that.

p.s. I humbly request a casuistry competition. Please comment with some of the more intriguing examples of casuistry you have found.

Labels: , , , ,

11.17.2009

Wine Tasting, Vodka and Reason


Seeing the above bumper sticker in Washington DC this weekend, I was faced once again with the false dichotomy between religion and critical thought. Atheists, 'positive thinkers', and other ideologists like to believe that unlike religious people, they actually employ their immutable power of reason or thinking.

But how effective are our powers of reason? More often than not, they are highly subjective, self serving and misleading. At the very least I would say that we have an inflated sense of our ability to reason consistently or objectively.

A recent article in the Wall Street Journal helped demonstrate this claim, highlighting the flaws and inconsistencies of the vital and influential wine rating system. One winemaker/statistician wondered why the same batch of wine he put out would win medals at one competition and absolutely nothing at the other. So he began a study of professional wine tasters and sommeliers. And what he and others have found is that the judges and 'experts' of these competitions are - surprise, surprise - inconsistent and often (unknowingly) very subjective and biased.
In one test, red food coloring was put into multiple glasses of a white wine to make it look like glasses of rose, Bordeaux, sherry etc. Although they were all the exact same wine, the testers thought they tasted like they were labeled. Similarly, 57 wine experts were served two glasses of the same wine. But they were poured from an expensive label bottle and a cheap table wine. A significant portion of the 'experts' chose the expensive label over the cheap one.

Okay, you say, we are easily tricked, and these tactics are not exactly fair. It gets better. The same wine/statistician also found out that wine experts were inconsistent. In a test of a hundred or so wines, a few were unknowingly 'resubmitted' or re-tested. The research found that the same expert rated the same wine differently each time (sometimes by as much as 4 points). GM Pucilowski, the chief judge at the California State Fair wine competition, finally allowed the results of this study to be published last year:

"I'm happy we did the study," said Mr. Pucilowski, "though I'm not exactly happy with the results. We have the best judges, but maybe we humans are not as good as we say we are."

Eureka!

I remember a 20/20 episode a few years ago where 10 relatively young New Yorkers were asked what their favorite vodka was. They all said things like "Grey Goose is totally my vodka", and "Stoli all the way." Then they took them out to a bar in Manhattan to do some blind taste tests of vodka and Cosmopolitans. They all hated the drinks with Grey Goose and Stoli, but they overwhelmingly loved one brand in particular: the economically priced Smirnoff vodka. The elite image and high cost of the product changed the way it tasted!



These studies remind us just how blind we are to ourselves. Whether you are Renee Descartes or the 'reasonable' Richard Dawkins, you may not want to put all your eggs in the human brain basket. Otherwise you will eventually look foolish.

One of the fundamental prerequisites for the Gospel is that belief that you/me (including your/my brain) are utterly insufficient to the task of life. Unfortunately, that reality is impossible to recognize or to make sense of on your own. Outside Help is needed.

Unmerited grace and limitless forgiveness do not make 'sense.' They are, however, very Wise.

1 Corinthians 1:20-23:

Where is the wise man? Where is the scribe? Where is the debater of this age? Has not God made foolish the wisdom of the world?
For since, in the wisdom of God, the world did not know God through wisdom, it pleased God through the folly of what we preach to save those who believe.
For Jews demand signs and Greeks seek wisdom,
but we preach Christ crucified, a stumbling block to Jews and folly to Gentiles,

Labels: , ,

5.11.2009

Go to Church!

As America tries to catch up with Europe in declining church attendance, some people are actually trying to figure out why no one likes religion anymore.

This article from the Washington Post entitled A Faith for The Nones depicts the vast majority of 20-somethings (called "nones") who are secular and religiously unaffiliated. Put off by the legalism and political nature of the institutional church, the article describes the unfortunately polarized state of religion in the United States. What is really insightful about this article is that they actually have the right solution! A rare thing indeed.

The last two paragraphs are exactly what Mockingbird is all about:

But Putnam regards the growth of the "nones" as a spike, not a permanent trend. The young, in general, are not committed secularists. "They are not in church, but they might be if a church weren't like the religious right. . . . There are almost certain to be religious entrepreneurs to fill that niche with a moderate evangelical religion, without political overtones."

In the diverse, fluid market of American religion there may be a demand, in other words, for grace, hope and reconciliation -- for a message of compassion and healing that appeals to people of every political background. It would be revolutionary -- but it would not be new.

Labels: , , ,

3.30.2009

Hannibal Lector on Why We Need To Be Killed Daily



"We feel murderous things in our lives, and anyone who denies it is a liar. We're taught as children to repress all that stuff: Don't be greedy, don't be angry. We bury the feelings alive, and they never die. I think when you project on screen an arch-villain, whether it's Heath Ledger's Joker or Hannibal Lecter, it gets something to respond in us. It's making us acknowledge that we have those parts of ourselves."

- Anthony Hopkins in a recent Entertainment Weekly article.

See Sean's Paulson post below.

Labels: , , ,

1.23.2009

The Gospel and Football

It is not often that ESPN articles bring me close to tears. But this one was an exception. Tony Dungy, coach of the Super Bowl Champion Indianapolis Colts and the reviver of the Tampa Bay Buccaneers franchise, retired this January. The article reflected on what made this coach one of the most respected in the business.

In 1997 the Tampa Bay Buccaneers were off to an unheard of 5-0 season start. Then their kicker started missing easy field goals and even extra points. Their story book season was collapsing and the entire football world (media and fans) were calling for the kicker, Mike Husted, to be benched. His performance was failing, it was costing the team games, so three strikes and get him out or risk ruining the season. It was an obvious no brainer decision. The article continued:

It was obvious to everyone, it seemed, except Dungy. Week after week, he stood there with his arms folded on the sidelines, never showing the slightest emotion when Husted missed a kick. The Bucs lost three games in a row.

Any other coach would have simply brought in another kicker. But Dungy had laid out a philosophy that would end up applying to every player he ever coached and he had to stick to it. He knew something the rest of the world didn't.

While media and fans were breaking down Husted's kicking technique, Dungy knew what was in the kicker's head and heart.

The real story here was Husted's mother, Ann, was dying of cancer up in Virginia...

The next morning, Dungy called and Husted was sure he was being cut. Dungy's words said something else.

"He just said, 'You're a Buccaneer. You're part of our family. You're our kicker,''' Husted said.

Mission accomplished. The next Sunday, the Bucs went up to Indianapolis. Husted made a game-winning field goal that broke his slump. The season was saved and the Bucs went on to make the playoffs for the first time in a generation.

"What he did was relieve the pressure from me,'' Husted said. "A lot of other coaches would have just let me go. I'm forever grateful to Tony for how he handled that. It speaks a lot about the type of individual he is and how he's not going to let outside forces influence what he knows is right.''

"I think the biggest thing was you never wanted to disappoint coach Dungy because of how he treated you,'' Husted said. "I think any player who ever played for him will tell you it was an honor to play for him.”

This is the power of the gospel but foolishness to the world. All conventional wisdom said punish the failure in order to produce results. Tony Dungy (a Christian BTW) instead loved the failure and not only did it produce results, but it helped and comforted a sad and wounded human being.

Labels: , ,

1.09.2009

Crossing The Line



I read an interesting article a week ago about a wealthy clubbin’ hemophiliac Episcopal priest (a particular area of interest for me). The article reported that this minister makes trips to New York City (where he also receives medical treatments) to frequent clubs where he spends tens of thousands of dollars on drinks and even tips very generously.

While the story is very interesting in and of itself, what fascinated me most was the response of his Bishop who temporarily removed him from all active ministries. In an another article, the Bishop said that if the accusations were true,

Such actions “portray an unacceptable idea of Christian stewardship.” The money reportedly spent in one night “would build and equip an African school or totally underwrite the homeless shelter we are building in Scranton.”



All feelings for Scranton aside, how do we really draw the line between appropriate and inappropriate spending? It seems to be ok to judge someone’s spending habits or any other habits only when they are really bad, out of balance, or not in moderation. After we have made the judgment that a particular action is too far out of line, we pull something like the ‘poor people card’ that the Bishop did in the above quote.


In the Sermon on the Mount Jesus makes qualitative as opposed to quantitative judgments about doing wrong. In other words, your actions either measure up or they do not, there is no in between. Whether its murder vs. anger, adultery vs. lust, or retaliation vs. giving, Jesus says that they are both wrong and liable for punishment. He does not give any leeway. This understanding of our actions, thankfully, drives us to the fact that we are in desperate need of death and resurrection (qualitative change) as opposed to need of improvement (quantitative change).


Following the qualitative line of thought, the Bishop should actually remove everyone from his ministry! Whether it is eating out versus brown bagging your lunch or buying too nice of a car that crosses the line (Toyota Camry is ok but the Avalon is unnaceptable!), all of us fall desperately short at some point.

Fortunately for us there is a different way, “we have and Advocate with the Father, Jesus Christ the righteous,” (1 John 2:1).

Labels: , ,

3.10.2008

Eliot Spitzer and the "Peter Principle"

A good friend of Mockingbird, The Rev. Alex Large, just sent me an email regarding the recent news surrounding New York Governor Spitzer. It just had to be shared with everyone.

This is from an article in the NYTimes about comments on blogs regarding Spitzer's downfall:

"That any governor would be snared in a prostitution ring is stunning enough, many commenters suggested, but Governor Spitzer, the very man who built himself up to be the epitome of the fearless, incorruptible lawman, who pledged to bring ethics reform to Albany as the self-described Steamroller?

"This breaks my heart," said one commenter, identified as Tom K., on the Times Web site. "I had hopes for Spitzer to finally break the long chain of corruption in politics. Why is it so hard for people to just be good?"

Another commenter, identified as Tom Conroy, had this to say: "Spitzer's governorship, thus far, has been a case book example of the 'Peter Principle' at work. A hitherto successful public servant has stumbled badly, perhaps irrevocably, by rising above the limit of his own competence."

Labels: , , , ,