3.30.2010

Whoops! Is My Elevated Anthropology Showing?

From the current Vanity Fair interview with Joel Osteen, the mega-pastor of America's largest church:
“Have you ever sinned?”

“Oh, sure,” [Osteen] answered surprisingly. “I’m sure I have. I mean, I think we’ve all sinned, so I can’t say that I’ve never … ” He looked suddenly bashful. “I’ve never done anything you’d call ‘terrible.’ I haven’t done drugs. Victoria’s the only girl I’ve ever dated.” Victoria, his glamorous wife of 22 years, is also a pastor. “I’m probably squeaky clean—I don’t have to say it,” Mr. Osteen added.
One's anthropology, theologically speaking, is one's doctrine of man. (See the Mockingbird-approved definition here.) The concept covers lots of territory. But the key question here is, in relation to God, what is a human being capable of? Is a human being able to please God? Osteen's response indicates a pretty robust sense of his own abilities towards righteousness (i.e., a high anthropology), and a shockingly lightweight view of sin. It appears that to him, sin is simply bad things we do, and thus can simply stop doing. The fact that anyone could be acquainted with the Bible (Romans 3, anyone?), and a pastor to boot, and still think of himself as "squeaky clean" is stunning. Because if one can be squeaky clean, what need does one have for (as the old hymn goes) a fountain fill'd with blood?

Jesus never said, "Be squeaky clean." Rather, he said, "Be perfect as your heavenly Father is perfect." And that's why I'm so glad for Good Friday.

Labels: , , ,

5 Comments:

Blogger DZ said...

holy moly.

March 30, 2010 at 5:19 PM  
Blogger StampDawg said...

Our beloved PZ once said of Ted Haggard that his problem wasn't homosexuality but being surronded by Bad Theological Companions. There you go.

The thing that struck me most is that Osteen's first response was to say that he "must have" at some point in his life -- but only based on a kind of abstract reasoning. Not based on any kind of personal memory.

Like if you asked me about my own sins it'd be like a whole parade of sinfulness JUST IN THE LAST THREE MINUTES. Where to start?

Stunning that a man could view even just his last few days and not see anything wrong with it.

March 30, 2010 at 5:44 PM  
Blogger Aaron M. G. Zimmerman said...

Here's another quote from the interview:
"Well, I think, John, that God gives you your own will and choices. I don’t believe that we’re supposed to drag ourselves through life defeated and not see God’s blessings. But you have to make the right choices and follow that still, small voice within you. Because I think that’s how God leads us.”

That last sentence, I think, is pretty dangerous.

March 30, 2010 at 9:45 PM  
Blogger dpotter said...

Osteen is a pretty easy target, but even this is shocking. Notice how once one lowers the bar of Law, Jesus must become a life coach. His high anthropology has eclipsed the Son. (pun intended)
The saddest thing is that Osteen has generated a massive following of people who will not only come to believe the same thing about themselves, but will perpetuate this myth to their children and grandchildren. The irreplaceable value of sound theological education, folks. Thanks Aaron.

March 31, 2010 at 3:23 AM  
Blogger Frank Sonnek said...

the opposite of evil and sin is not goodness. the opposite of sin is faith. "That which is not of faith is sin".

He says he is squeeky clean. I believe him. So what.

March 31, 2010 at 9:10 AM  

Post a Comment

Subscribe to Post Comments [Atom]

<< Home