11.04.2010

Tryin' To Get Down To The Heart Of The Matter...

According to a recent survey, more Americans desire forgiveness in their lives than are willing to forgive others. The details are unsurprising, but interesting. Many of the hold-outs suggested that those who commit violent or sexual crimes are unforgivable, and a whopping 60% said 'forgiving someone would first depend on the offender apologizing and making changes'.

In addition, the majority of Americans polled said they 'sought the advice of friends and family rather than religious leaders when grappling with issues of forgiveness', 25% said they 'did not know where to go for help with spiritual needs', while a third of respondents 'struggle with spirituality'.

These results are, in fact, much too conservative. My feeling is that the true numbers ought to be about 100% in every case. Almost nobody knows what in the world is going on (existentially speaking), including myself; and our true selves emerge spontaneously, not after we have a moment to mull over the best answer to the pollster's question. So the margin of error in polls like these is influenced less by the sample size (in this case, N=1000...where my stats nerds at?), and more by the respondent's desire to respond as the idealized self. The reality, of course, is that the numbers would have been the same had the poll been conducted within the church. Thank goodness that Christ was pro-active in His forgiveness, even calling out from the cross on behalf of his murderers, 'Father, forgive them!' Yes, and forgive us too.

Labels: , , , ,

2 Comments:

Blogger DZ said...

Absolutely fascinating stuff. Thanks Dylan. 100% indeed!

November 4, 2010 at 10:21 AM  
Blogger StampDawg said...

"So the margin of error in polls like these is influenced less by the sample size... and more by the respondent's desire to respond as the idealized self."

You are absolutely right! This is a crucial issue in survey methodology and is often overlooked.

It's what I was alluding to in a thread a week or two ago where the discussion partly was about why people were unchurched.

On the one hand, we should (and do here at MB) take seriously people's self-perceptions as to why they don't want to go to church.

At the same time, we have to remember that it's a VERY dirty test tube! If for a particular person, the real reason is that the culture now gives him the freedom to not go to church, and he just feels like sleeping in on Sunday, it's going to be very tempting for him to give high sounding justifications, which make him a deeply principled victim of Bad Religious People, rather than the truth.

A great aphorism that came out of the Reformation is:

What the heart desires,
the will chooses,
and the mind justifies.

The mind is a notoriously poor judge of why the whole human does what it does -- and when the mind is its most aware, typically says "I do not understand what I do." (Romans 7:15)

November 4, 2010 at 12:15 PM  

Post a Comment

Subscribe to Post Comments [Atom]

<< Home